The Red Tent By Anita Diamant: A Timeless Tale of Sisterhood and Strength (Part 1). The Book Review

Spoiler Alert: This review delves deeply into the first half of The Red Tent and contains significant plot points. Sensitivity Warning: Some aspects of this review may challenge Christian readers, particularly those sensitive to differing interpretations of biblical stories.

I listened to a recorded version of this book (an audiobook) using Audible. I don't think I've ever been this impressed with Audible since I became a member in 2013. It's rare to find a combination of a book as good as this one is, paired with an excellent narrator's performance. I find that you get one or the other. This one hits 10 out of 10 for both.

I’ve always believed that truly great books are those you can read repeatedly and feel as though you’re discovering them anew each time. For me, The Red Tent by Anita Diamant is exactly that book. This is my third time reading it, and each time feels as fresh and mesmerising as the first. It’s not only my favourite book of all time but also one that evokes a sense of wonder and reverence every single time I open its pages.

From the very first paragraph, The Red Tent captivates. The opening sets the tone for an extraordinary story—a hidden history brought to life by Dinah, the only daughter of Jacob, whose voice was silenced in the Bible. The subheading, “the oldest love story never told,” (I later discovered that not all the book versions have this subheading, but mine did) couldn’t be more apt.

In this blog, I’ll explore the themes, characters, and cultural details from the first half of the book that make it so utterly compelling to me.

The Untold Story of Dinah

One of the most striking themes in The Red Tent is how history is written by the victors—often men—and how women’s voices are lost in the process. Dinah’s story, as recounted in the Bible, is a shadow of what Diamant offers us: a richly detailed narrative that reclaims her truth. Unlike the biblical account, where Dinah is described as a victim of rape, here she tells us clearly—she wasn’t raped. This retelling gives her agency and challenges us to reconsider the ways in which women’s stories are distorted or erased altogether.

A Love Story of Mothers

The first half of the book isn’t a romantic love story—it’s about the love of Dinah’s mothers. Born into a polygamous family, Dinah grows up surrounded by four mothers: Leah, Rachel, Zilpah, and Bilhah. Their bond, though complex, is powerful. The way they care for Dinah, as the only girl, moved me deeply. They treat her with tenderness, pride, and hope, making her the centre of their collective world.

Their love extends to the shared rituals of the menstrual tent, which the women treat as sacred. The poetry Diamant uses to describe menstruation makes it feel like an honour rather than something taboo. The idea that the women synchronise their cycles and gather together in this space creates a strong sense of sisterhood and community. As archaic as it might sound, I can’t help but find something deeply special about it.

The Culture and Superstitions

Diamant’s rich descriptions of ancient customs and practices made me yearn for a time machine. The superstitions, rituals, and everyday life of these women feel so vivid and real, it’s as though you’re right there with them. I was especially drawn to the idea of “milk brothers” and how the birth of a daughter is described as “the birth of a birth-giver.” These cultural nuances bring the story to life and left me both enchanted and reflective about my own roots.

A Personal Connection

As someone from a large family who has experienced the loss of community after moving to England, The Red Tent touches a tender part of me. Dinah’s story reminds me of what it means to belong, to be surrounded by a community of women who share their lives, their struggles, and their joys. It’s a longing I think many readers will relate to, especially those who have been separated from their families or cultural traditions.

Complex Characters

The women of The Red Tent are some of the most complex and memorable characters I’ve ever encountered. Leah, with her sharp features and fiery spirit, makes me think of Tilda Swinton—regal, otherworldly, and unapologetically herself. Rebekah, the grandmother, is another standout. She’s a formidable figure—equal parts regal and ruthless. I’d love to see her on screen; she’d be the kind of villain you secretly admire.

High Stakes and High Emotions

The high mortality rate for mothers and babies during childbirth looms large in this story, reminding us of the fragility of life in ancient times. It’s heartbreaking but also makes the love and resilience of these women all the more powerful. Their shared stories of sex, love, and loss create an unbreakable bond—a bond that I, having attended an all-girls’ school, can say is both deeply familiar and timeless.

Favourite Quotes

Two quotes from the first half of the book have stayed with me:

1. “We knew that death was the shadow of birth, the price women pay for the honour of giving life.”

2. “If you want to know about a woman, you must first ask about her mother.”

These lines encapsulate so much of what makes The Red Tent special. The first acknowledges the bittersweet realities of womanhood, while the second highlights the generational connections that shape us all.

This is just a glimpse into the brilliance of The Red Tent. In Part 2 of this review, I’ll dive into the romantic love story that takes centre stage in the second half of the book, as well as the shocking betrayal that changes Dinah’s life forever. For now, I’ll leave you with this: if you haven’t read The Red Tent, what are you waiting for?

Stay tuned for Part 2, where we’ll continue exploring this remarkable story.

Do follow my social media page. And subscribe to my newsletter for more book reviews.